Source: California Invasive Plant Council


URL of this page: http://www.cal-ipc.org/ip/management/ipcw/pages/detailreport.cfm@usernumber=29&surveynumber=182.php

Invasive Plants of California's Wildland

Cirsium arvense
Scientific name   Cirsium arvense
Additional name information:   (L.) Scop.
Common name   Canada thistle, California thistle, creeping thistle, corn thistle, perennial thistle, field thistle
Synonymous scientific names   Cirsium lanatum, Serratula arvense
Closely related California natives   20
Closely related California non-natives:   3
Listed   CalEPPC List B,CDFA B
By:   David Bayer
Distribution  
cirsium-arv-map

HOW DO I RECOGNIZE IT?
Distinctive features:  

Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense) is a persistent perennial thistle that grows vigorously, forming dense colonies and spreading by roots growing horizontally that give rise to aerial shoots. Plants generally grow one to four feet tall, but on occasion may grow more than six feet tall and branch freely. Stems are smooth, mostly without spiny wings, green and glabrous. Flower heads are numerous, small, and almost spineless. Flowers are purplish lavender or, less commonly, white.

Description:  
Asteraceae. Perennial, vigorous plant that spreads by horizontally growing root stalks. Stems: smooth, mostly without spiny wings, green and glabrous. Plants 1-4 ft (30-120 cm) tall with green foliage. Leaves: alternate, margins variable from entire to deeply lobed, 2-8 in (5-20 cm) in length, sessile, slightly clasping or shortly decurrent. Spines along margins of leaf 1/8-3/8 in (3-5 mm) in length. Inflorescence: flowerheads small, 0.4-1 in (1-2.5 cm) diameter and approximately 1 in (2.5 cm) tall, rounded or flat-topped; involucre hemispheric to ovoid, outer phyllaries ovate, tipped with stout spines 1/16 in (1 mm), inner phyllaries progressively longer with tips flattened. Flowers: plants dioecious with all flowerheads either pistillate (female) or staminate (male). Florets all tubular, generally purplish lavender to, less commonly, white.
cirsium-arv-illus

Staminate flowers (male) with corolla 1/2 in (12-13 mm) long, tube 1/3 in (8 mm) and lobes 1/8 in (3-4 mm). Pistillate flowers (female) with corolla 3/5-3/4 in (14-20 mm) long, tube 3/8-5/8 in (10-16 mm), and lobes 1/16-1/8 in (2-3 mm). Pappus abundant, white, feathery (branched), to 3/4-1 3/4 in (20-30 mm) long and fragile, easily broken off at the achene. Fruits: achenes light brown, approximately 1/8 in (3 mm) long, slightly grooved along long axis, flattened, and occasionally curved. There is an inconspicuous yellow rim at the apex where the pappus joins the seed with a small conical point in the center. Base of seed slightly rounded (Hickman 1993).

 

WHERE WOULD I FIND IT?  

Canada thistle is common throughout northern California, including the Sierra Nevada, Modoc Plateau, Central Valley, Coast Range, and San Francisco Bay Area. Although less vigorous in southern California, it has been found along the coast as far south as Orange and Riverside counties. Inland it is also known to occur in Kern County and in montane areas of Fresno, Inyo, and Mono counties (Barbe 1990). The southern distribution is probably limited by high temperatures.

Canada thistle grows on a variety of soil types. It does well on deep, well aerated, moist loam soils, but is known to grow in dry habitats and on sandy soils. It may also grow on stream banks, in meadows, and even in wet ditches, but it will not survive in saturated soil. It is intolerant of shade, requiring good light conditions for aggressive growth (Moore 1975, White et al. 1993).

Canada thistle infests many habitats such as cultivated fields, roadsides, pastures and rangeland, railway embankments, and lawns. It is a major pest in streamside grasslands from the Pacific Northwest eastward to the plains. It also invades moist prairies.

WHERE DID IT COME FROM AND HOW IS IT SPREAD?  

Canada thistle is native to southeastern Europe and the eastern Mediterranean area. It has spread to most temperate parts of the world and is considered an important weed in thirty-seven countries (Parsons 1992). It is particularly troublesome in cooler areas of North America, extending from coast to coast in both Canada and the United States. It was introduced into North America in the seventeenth century by French settlers as a contaminant in crop seed (Moore 1975). It was probably introduced into California the same way.

Canada thistle spreads by seed, either by wind or as a contaminant in crop seed. The pappus is fragile and easily separated from the seed, so most seeds stay in the vicinity of parent plants. The seeds float and are easily distributed by water. Seeds can be spread in mud attached to farm equipment. Infested packing material has also contributed to its spread.

Once established, Canada thistle spreads rapidly by horizontal roots, up to several meters per year. The extensive horizontal root system assures long-term persistence and spread by vegetative means. A segment of root as small as 1/8 to 3/8 inch (3-6 mm) in length and 1/16 inch (1 mm) in diameter is able to propagate a new plant and is easily spread with plant material or by equipment (Rogers 1928, White 1979).

WHAT PROBLEMS DOES IT CAUSE?  

Canada thistle is considered a noxious weed in California, and in many states it is considered one of the most serious pests to agriculture. In North America heavy infestations reduce yields of spring cereals by 40 to 70 percent. Canada thistle occurs on 40 percent of cultivated lands of the Canadian prairie provinces, and loss of wheat in Saskatchewan alone was estimated to be worth $4 million in 1980. Approximately one million hectares of grassland are infested in England and Wales (Parsons 1992). Once established, Canada thistle is a fierce competitor for nutrients and water needed by crops or native plants. It produces allelopathic chemicals that assist in displacing competing plant species (Stachion and Zimdahl 1980). It has been reported to accumulate nitrates that cause poisoning in animals (Fuller and McClintock 1986). The spiny leaves scratch animal skin, sometimes causing infection, or, at a minimum, restrict animal grazing in heavily infested areas (Moore 1975).

HOW DOES IT GROW AND REPRODUCE?  

In established plants of Canada thistle, carbohydrates move from the root system up to the newly forming shoots as growth starts in spring. As leaves on the shoots develop, photosynthates start moving to newly developing roots and flowerheads. The developing flowerheads take more and more of the energy (photosynthates) produced by the leafy stems and stored in the roots. Carbohydrates in the root system are at their lowest when the plant begins flowering. As seeds develop, photosynthates start moving down into the root system again and, after the seed reaches maturity, carbohydrate movement to the root system continues until frost kills the foliage.

cirsium-arv-large2

Canada thistle typically flowers from late June through August. Male and female flowers are borne on separate plants. Seed production thus depends on having both male and female plants present within 330 feet (100 m) of each other, which often requires at least two introductions. It is rare to find a clone of Canada thistle that has both female and male parts in the same flower or that produces more than the occasional apomictic seed (Hodgson 1964, 1968).

(click on photos to view larger image)

cirsium-arv-small2

Pollination is almost exclusively by insects. Male and female plants growing in close proximity result in high rates of seed production, with some plants producing over 5,000 seeds per plant. Viable seeds are formed eight to ten days following pollination. Seeds mature in late summer or early fall. They may germinate immediately after falling from the plant if conditions are favorable, or they may remain dormant in the soil for up to twenty-one years (Detmers 1927, Moore 1975, Lalonde and Roitberg 1994). Seeds that germinate immediately form a rosette that overwinters and flowers the following summer. However, germination of most seeds is delayed until spring (Moore 1975). Approximately 90 percent of seeds germinate within one year. Some seeds remain dormant in the soil for several years. Viability is a function of age of seed and depth in the soil. The deeper the seed is buried, the longer the viability. Ideal conditions for germination are abundant soil moisture and temperatures averaging 20 to 30 degrees C (White 1979). Seedling survival is poor. Seedlings do not establish in areas with existing groundcover and survive only on disturbed or bare areas in unshaded situations (Parsons 1992). Seedlings develop rapidly, first developing a taproot. Approximately six to eight weeks later, plants develop lateral roots that grow more-or-less horizontally. These lateral roots last approximately two years before they die and disintegrate. In the meantime, they produce new shoots and plants, resulting in a clonal infestation that spreads outward rapidly, approaching twenty feet (6 m) in a single season (Donald 1990). Despite the taproot, over half of the root system grows in the top twelve inches (30 cm) of soil. Roots go much deeper than that, however, with some vertical roots penetrating fifteen to twenty feet (5-7 m) deep (Haderlie et al. 1987). New plants readily emerge from small root fragments. Shoots can emerge from root fragments at a depth of at least twenty inches (50 cm). Within two years, plants can produce over sixty-six feet (20 m) of new roots (Parsons 1992). Growth is prolific, and patches exist with 130 shoots per square meter.

HOW CAN I GET RID OF IT?  

The most effective method of control depends on the site, the extent of the infestation, the presence or absence of both male and female flowering plants, growth characteristics of the plant, and the impact of the control method on non-target species. The many ecotypes respond differently to control measures. There is no easy method of control, and all methods require follow-up. Combinations of mechanical, cultural, and chemical methods are more effective than any single method used alone (Trumble and Kok, 1982).

Regardless of the method or methods selected, competition from other plants should always be considered in the control program. Because of the longevity of viable seeds in the seedbank and the short time from germination to perennation, monitoring of control sites to locate and eliminate new seedlings and resprouts is essential. The site should be monitored at least twice a year for the first four years, and should follow rain or irrigation by a month to six weeks. Monitoring should be more frequent at the beginning of a control program and can become less frequent with time.

Physical control:  

Mechanical methods: Cultivation is not generally recommended unless it is carried out with care and persistence, because it often increases the problem by spreading root fragments to new locations. Repeated cultivation at regular intervals of twenty days is effective in exhausting the remaining root fragments but does not kill ungerminated seeds. Care needs to be taken not to remove or disturb other desired native plants in the area. Cultivation must start as soon as the plants first emerge in late winter. Shallow cultivation in hot, dry weather is best.

Repeated mowing at three-week intervals will weaken the plant, prevent flowering, and seed production, and generally can be timed to avoid major impacts on desirable plants growing in the infested area.

Prescribed burning: Repeat burning has shown some reduction in old, established stands of Canada thistle, but overall control generally is less than satisfactory. Removal of old plant residue resulting from fire may promote earlier seed germination of native species (Olson, 1975).

Biological control:  

Insects and fungi: There are no effective biological control organisms available at this time. There are several insects, such as Cassida rubiginosa, Cleonus piger, Orellia ruficauda, and Vanessa cardui, that feed on Canada thistle and cause some damage, but none effectively control Canada thistle populations (Moore 1975, Maw 1976). O. ruficauda has been reported to be the most effective. The rust species Puccinia obtegens has shown some promise for controlling Canada thistle, but it must be used in conjunction with other control measures to be effective (Turner et al. 1980).

Grazing: Sheep and cattle graze on Canada thistle when the plants are young and tender, helping to deplete the root reserves. Recent New Zealand studies show that goat grazing can be effective. Grazing and trampling can increase stress on plants, enhancing the effectiveness of other control measures such as herbicides. Livestock tend to avoid grazing in and around dense patches of older plants. If young sheep eat older plants, their tender mouth parts may be damaged by the spines and become infected (Parsons 1992).
Plant competition: Vigorous competition from native plants is essential in achieving lasting control.

Chemical control:  

Chemical control should be used cautiously and in strict compliance with the label, realizing that some non-target plant species may be killed or seriously affected by the herbicide. Herbicides applied to the foliage will enter the plant and be translocated or move with water in the transpiration stream. Those herbicides that land on the soil may be taken up by the roots and transported in the plant by water in the transpiration stream. Herbicide use must be timed to the growth stage and physiology of Canada thistle (Tworkoski, 1992) and is most effective when used in combination with competition from other plants. Thorough coverage of all foliage of an infestation (clones) is essential because all shoots from infestations over two years old may not be interconnected. Properly timed repeat applications of selected herbicides will always be necessary to achieve complete control of Canada thistle. Applications may be made either in spring or in fall, but fall applications have provided the most control from a single application.

Glyphosate is a non-selective foliar applied herbicide that will kill or seriously injure all growing vegetation with which it comes in contact. Once it penetrates a plant, it is transported efficiently from cell to cell. It has little or no soil residual except on light, sandy soil low in organic matter. Applications should be made soon after flowering when photosynthates are moving from the foliage to the roots. When the first application is properly timed, extensive injury will occur to the developing root system. A second application or another herbicide will be necessary to kill the crown and new shoots arising from old roots that were not affected by the first application.

Triclopyr, dicamba, and 2,4-D are all foliar-applied herbicides that may seriously affect grasses and other monocots as well as many dicotyledon plants. Like glyphosate, they are efficiently transported from cell to cell once they enter the plant’s tissue. They all have some soil residual, but dicamba has the longest (up to six months). Application should be made when Canada thistle is actively growing and when photosynthates are being translocated from leaves to roots.

Clopyralid or clopyralid + 2,4-D has shown good control of Canada thistle where the root system has been disturbed. These herbicides are foliar applied and generally have a soil residual of one to two months. Repeat applications for two to four years generally have provided complete elimination of established root systems. Caution should be exercised because many broadleaf plants may be injured. Clopyralid leaches readily, especially in open sandy soil.